i wish
where it hurts
What a strange feeling to watch Mitch Winehouse, father of the Amy who died young, telling the camera after her death how he felt it was not his place to save her. You can’t force treatment on somebody, he says, and shrugs. Meantime he is running the Amy Winehouse Foundation, his income derived from her work. After everything that’s happened, still an unawakened person: living in an unreflecting stupor, so it seemed, entirely selfish, he has milked his cow to death and still has no idea what went down, or who she was, or what life is like for a sensitive – that is, a wakeful – person.
It is cold in Berlin at night the end of the summer, I drew my feet up on the chair. Two dogs kept tangling in a hassle of growls every time someone got up to buy a beer. Would be great, said the announcer in English and in German, if you could all carry your deckchairs over to the stacks afterwards, and bring your ashtrays back. Her fingers tangling in her afro loomed larger behind her like fame.
The last film I saw here, a month ago, was about another tormented musical artist: Brian Wilson. I remember afterwards standing in the queue laughing as though crying again, watching all the Germans patiently waiting, chairs folded, to hand back their deckchairs to the two fellows rapidly stacking and folding.
Today I discovered I have cried so much in the last week that the skin round my nostrils is all chapped and eroded. Standing in front of the mirror rubbing oil into it in little tiny circles I was thinking of the psychologist I spoke to on Friday, a much younger woman I have met a few times now, who is Danish. We speak in English. She said, I am sorry that these sessions just involve an hour and after that I have to let you walk out into the world all alone. I wish I could come with you for a few hours, and spend the afternoon beside you, just sitting with you. “There is nothing I would like more,” she said. I walked across the bare floor of the old sewing factory to the bathroom and dunked my face in the cold water several times, patting down the aggrieved and swollen skin, the red. I tipped my bag onto the floor and twenty-one sodden tissues rolled out on the tile. Later that night woken by street noise and unable to stop from weeping I rang my parents’ house. It was 3am here, there almost noon. “Have you tried concentrating on the positive things in life?” My dad searched for something to say when I became so entrailed in sobs I no longer could speak. “I meant to tell you,” he said, “about the friend from Engineers Australia I ran into at the spinal clinic. Lovely bloke. But he has broken his neck and now he’s paralysed from the neck down.”
Amy Winehouse’s ex husband, the reprehensible Blake Incarcerated, lounged in his splendid corner chair. He was being made up for a biopic about his famous wife, had filled out, was feeling self-assured. He spoke about himself and then rolled on over her, already dead. Wha’ I fought was, he said Londonishly, the emblem of fake punk, I’m earning good money now, I’m a good looking man, I dress well – what ve hell am I doin’ wasting my time wiv ‘er? He had drawn her into the tiny heroin room, and left her there. In the film she climbed onstage, booed by the people who’d been chanting her name, and began beseechingly hugging one big black man after another – musicians who reminded her, I would imagine, of one of her only true friends, a bodyguard who used to stop her from going out for more booze. Her girlhood friend’s voice broke describing how they had rung the father imploring him, please, do not let her tour. But she ‘ad commitments, innit. So he put his wretched daughter, skinny and cowering, on stage in Belgrade, where she stood trembling and evasive until she was booed off.
In the outdoor audience, no one stirred. The story was heartbreaking and base. A person eaten alive by the public, undefended by her nearest loves. We were aware in our deck chairs that we had all feasted on her, like Diana, like Marilyn. We are entitled to feed on the female: the role of a woman is to cater our eye.
A slight wind rattled the screen. In eerie silence they showed slowly the unhappy photographs she had taken of herself in her house in a daze, a woman hounded on the street. She only had to show her face at a window to be blinded all over by mega flash bulbs. Her husband himself and her father, deserter of his family when his daughter was ten, are in their own ways mega-flash bulbs, though dim: yet both have survived and now flourish on the messy heap of her memory and her fame.
We are a cruel culture. We trash the wild. The queue round the corner to see this girl’s life, the silence that spread from one person to another, were a searching in the self and a tribute. The film makers had pieced it all delicately together from the home movies she’s left behind – and from footage in the vocal booth – and from interviews with those who loved her and those who exploited her gift.
This outdoor cinema is set up in the green in front of a famous smoking squat, where rivers of drugs have been consumed. It now houses galleries, the summer cinema, and a restaurant which is always booked out. Gift in German means poison. Tony Bennett said, she had the true jazz voice. Jazz singers don’t want to be up in front of 50,000 people.
A breeze stirred the trees in the prolongued, painful silence. It was cold and growing dark round half a moon. We were Berliners, many of us people who have tried at some stage to suicide by substance. Four lights came on in the big house, a hospital before. She drank so much that her heart just stopped. The treetops stood there stately, shaking a little. I drew a sigh in the immaculate silence.
17 comments on “where it hurts”
Leave a comment
You might also like to read:
On the subway a woman suddenly opened her mouth and began to sing. Her voice was tentative and good. She had a little loudspeaker rigged up through her mobile phone and had set herself to ...read more
Every week I cross town on the train and we pass a tower block of identical grey-frame units which have grey balconies. One balcony, at eye level with the train, has a bright pink inflatable ...read more
At rehearsal with a Ghanaian band for whom it is imperative to have two different drummers side by side. There are three brass horn players and I have counted four different patterns of stenciled colour ...read more
As a parent of grown children, I can say that it is so hard to see them in pain. Whatever you say seems inadequate. Your dad meant well, but I don’t know if thinking about paraplegics helps.
My best friend once had the moving van with everything she owned stolen. She lost all of her photos (She was a tremendous photographer) and all her journals, etc. I said, “Well, at least you’re alive,” which I later realized was not at all helpful…If a person needs to mourn, she should mourn.
Thank you, Cynthia. I feel like this inability to rest with pain, to really sit with unbearable emotion and let it be, is what’s at the root of a lot of the damage we continue to do to each other & to ecosystems. It’s so frustrating. No one could buy sweatshop clothing, for example, if we didn’t turn away all that we know.
In Dad’s case I guess he was trying to make conversation and he’s awkward at it. Also, the horror of his colleague’s transformation was weighing on him. I felt afterwards I wished I had been able to sit with it… but the timing was brutal. The picture of this man’s life so horribly altered, and within a moment, went through me like fire.
That’s just very sad. I don’t know what else to say.
Sometimes that is the very best thing to say. It is hard to know how to respond to such a waste of youth & talent. I mean, she’d still be making music, fifty year career ahead of her. The songs growing more insightful. The performances deeper.
I’m thinking lately that humans are a failure as a species. There are notable exceptions for whom living in this miserable broth is very painful What if our intelligence evolved in cetacean bodies, not primate? I wonder.
What a novel thought. A failure as a species – very bleak.
It really is unbearable, almost. Seems like shutting yourself down is the most adaptive way to cope and also the best way to continue doing the damage this life does.
It will never stop!
Oh, Stephen. Please be wrong.
Oh, Cathoel. My love to you. Sorry I’ve been so quiet lately, you have been in my thoughts, though xx
It’s really nice to hear from you, Jameela. Thank you xx
Yeah, they sound like a bunch of parasites, but he’s right; you CAN’T force “treatment” or your mode of thinking onto people. Everyone is on their own journey and if someone seems to be in trouble on their journey you can offer them help, or render it when asked, but you can’t force it on them. (Not while they’re conscious anyway) As the late, great Billie Holiday put it,”Aint nobody’s business but my own”.
People love to be sanctimonious about “drug addicts”, especially drinkers and smokers. Example;
I was trying to get a lawyer associate of mine recently to help get an old friend of mine get out of remand on bail.(sure they’re a “drug addict” but a they’re a lovely, gentle person) Being poor tho, the Legal Profession wasn’t showing much interest in taking their case. “They may as well start drying out now,”: one pompously intoned.
I looked him in the eye,” Yeah mate, cos that always works so well doesn’t it? Throwing people into jail to cold turkey, oh yes..they always come out better after that.”
He stopped pontificating then.. Bastard should know better, he used to be a “Rad” once.
I guess this tension between the need to prevent people’s self destruction and the need to respect one another’s sovereignty is an elbow of love. In Winehouse Snr’s case it turns out (according to the film) he wasn’t around much for most of her childhood, so perhaps she idolised him. And perhaps he took advantage of that by ‘forcing’ or persuading her to keep touring whilst piously refraining from ‘forcing’ or encouraging her to seek treatment. Isn’t it interesting how radicalism can mature into another form of censoriousness.
I hope your friend finds support and peace. I’m glad you’ve stuck by them and been a good friend to their gentleness.
So tragic.
It’s painful, isn’t it. It felt like she just drowned in a tidal wave of over stimulation – the world of public fame to a sensitive person.
She was a genius jazz singer
I never realised that while she was alive! Didn’t know it at all until I watched this movie. The way they showcased (from footage of her life) the love she had for the jazz greats was really moving. And hearing Tony Bennett talk about her afterwards
Interesting thoughts and images, thanks Cathoel. Yes I have a theory that the only true freedom is happens when you are controlled, and absolute liberty, the most unnatural state imaginable, is inevitably crushing and pervertingto the soul.